Wire vs Plastic vs Soft Dog Crates: Which Type to Buy
Wire, plastic and soft crates each solve a different problem. Compare airflow, security, weight and travel use so you buy the right type the first time.
Buy a wire crate for home, a hard plastic crate for the car or airline cargo, and a soft crate only for a dog that is already reliably crate trained. Most owners need one wire crate and nothing else; the mistake is buying the travel type first because it looks tidier.
The four types compared
| Type | Airflow | Security | Weight | Folds flat | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wire | High | High with double latches | Heavy | Yes | Everyday home use |
| Hard plastic | Moderate, side vents | High, bolted shell | Moderate | No | Car travel, airline cargo |
| Soft-sided | High | Low, mesh panels | Very light | Yes | Trained dogs, short trips |
| Furniture-style | Moderate | Moderate | Heavy | No | Settled adults, living rooms |
Wire: the right default
A wire crate does the most jobs adequately and one job — house training a puppy — better than anything else, because it comes with a divider panel. You buy the crate the adult dog will need, block off the back, and move the divider forward as the puppy grows. One purchase covers the whole of puppyhood.
What to check:
- A divider is included, not sold separately.
- Two slide-bolt latches on any door over 30 inches.
- A removable plastic pan for the floor, ideally with a lip.
- Gauge of the wire, if published. Thin wire flexes; the bars should not move when you push them with a flat hand.
- Folding action. Nearly all fold, but some need tools.
The downsides are real: they are heavy, they clatter, and an anxious dog can catch a paw or a collar tag in the bars. Remove tags before crating, and drape a blanket over three sides if your dog settles better with less to look at.
Sizing is where most people get it wrong. Use the crate size chart rather than the box label.
Hard plastic: the travel shell
Plastic kennels are two moulded halves bolted together with a metal or plastic door. The enclosed shell makes them the den-like option, and the rigid structure is why they are the required style for airline cargo. If air travel is on the horizon, check the specific airline's requirements before you buy anything — the rules on door hardware, ventilation and labelling vary by carrier and change without much notice.
They do not fold, they take up permanent space, and the ventilation is poorer than a wire crate in a warm room. For travel-specific requirements and car use, that belongs with the travel guides rather than here.
Soft-sided: light, portable, conditional
Fabric over a collapsible frame, usually with mesh panels and a carry strap. They weigh a fraction of a wire crate, pack into a bag, and are genuinely pleasant to move.
The condition is the dog. Mesh gives under teeth and claws, zips are not locks, and no crate of any material should be called escape-proof. A soft crate is for a dog that goes in, lies down, and sleeps — a trained adult at an agility trial or a hotel room. It is not a containment solution for a puppy, a chewer, or a dog with separation anxiety.
Furniture-style: an upgrade, not a starter
Wooden end-table crates solve an aesthetic problem for people whose dog is past the destructive stage. The panels are wood or veneer, the latches are usually lighter duty, and a teething adolescent will eat the corners. Treat it as something you buy in year three, not year one.
Matching type to situation
| Your situation | Buy this |
|---|---|
| New puppy, house training | Wire with divider, adult size |
| Adult dog, home use, chews bedding | Wire, with a thin waterproof mat |
| Regular car trips | Hard plastic sized to the boot |
| Airline cargo travel | Hard plastic meeting that airline's rules |
| Dog shows, camping, hotels | Soft, for a trained dog only |
| Settled senior, living room | Furniture-style or wire with a cover |
What goes in the crate
Bedding is a separate decision from the crate. A puppy or chewer wants a thin washable mat you will not mind replacing; a settled adult can have a proper bed. If your dog shreds everything you put in, see dog beds for chewers.
How to introduce the crate — the training side of this — is covered in the training guides. Buying the right box is the easy half.
What to do next
If you are buying one crate and only one, make it a wire crate in the adult size for your dog's breed, with a divider and two latches. Add a plastic kennel later if travel demands it, and add a soft crate only once your dog treats a crate as a nap spot.
Current options and prices sit on the dog crates hub.
Our picks for this
MidWest iCrate Double-Door Folding Crate, 36" (Medium-Large Breeds, 41–70 lb)
🏆 Best Overall Crate
Tradeoff: Determined escape artists can bend the wire.
Amazon Basics Single-Door Folding Wire Crate with Divider, 36"
💰 Best Value Crate
Tradeoff: Lighter wire than the iCrate, and one door means fewer placement options.
Frequently asked questions
Can a dog escape from a soft crate?
A determined dog can get through mesh, and no crate should be described as escape-proof. Soft crates suit dogs that already settle quietly in a crate and treat it as a bed. If your dog scratches, chews the door, or panics when left, a soft crate is the wrong tool and a wire crate with a solid latch is the safer choice.
Do dogs prefer wire or plastic crates?
It depends on the dog. Wire crates give more airflow and sightlines, which suits dogs that like to see the room. Plastic crates are enclosed and darker, which suits dogs that settle better in a den. You can make a wire crate feel enclosed by draping a blanket over three sides, which is the cheapest way to test the preference.
How many latches should a crate door have?
Two on anything larger than about 30 inches. A single centre latch lets the door flex at the corners, and a dog leaning on it can work it open. Slide-bolt latches at the top and bottom of the door spread the load and are much harder to defeat.
Is a furniture-style crate worth it?
For a settled adult dog that no longer chews, yes — it stops the crate looking like equipment in your living room. For a puppy or a teething adolescent it is an expensive chew toy, since the panels are wood or veneer. Wait until the crate is genuinely just a bed before you upgrade to one.
Found this useful?
Add MyPetGuid as a preferred source on Google and our guides show up more often in your Search results and AI Overviews.